Watching with Warner: BROTHER ORCHID (1940)

I have been a fan of the Warner Archive since the beginning.  The idea of a treasury of rare, unknown, and hard to find movies available for purchase as made-to-order DVDs was a glorious treat to a classic film fan and collector.  Recently, I have discovered their fantastic podcast to which I have quickly become addicted.  Through the podcast I have found more classic films to buy and add to my collection (Thanks George, DW, and Matt!), as well as the new streaming video on demand (SVOD) service aka WARNER ARCHIVE INSTANT.  I am currently trying my free month trial but I am sure that I will be continuing my subscription well after.  It is from the WARNER ARCHIVE INSTANT service that we find our next film…from Warner Brothers in 1940, BROTHER ORCHID.

I wasn’t sure what to expect from this movie but I decided that any film with Edward G. Robinson and Humphrey Bogart was definitely worth a look!  Edward G. Robinson stars as Johnny Sarto, the boss of a racketeering gang.  After becoming disgusted with the gangland underworld, Johnny decides to quit the racketeering business and travel to Europe in search of “class”.  Jack Buck, played by Humphrey Bogart, is Johnny’s second in command who takes over the gang upon Johnny’s departure.  Johnny also has a devoted girlfriend named Flo, played by Ann Sothern, who wants nothing more than to travel with Johnny and to be his wife.  But that isn’t the sort of class that Johnny is going for, so before he leaves he sets Flo up with a position as a hat check girl at a night club.

Over the next five years Johnny travels all over Europe, spending money on all the finest things and getting fleeced in the process.  At the end of it all he is broke with nothing to show for it.  There is nothing left to do but to return to the big city from whence he came and reclaim his position as a gangland kingpin.  Upon his return everything seems normal, his boys are all happy to see him and they even bought him his favorite orchids to celebrate.  But all is not as it seems, as Johnny soon finds out.  While he was gone, Jack Buck has taken over and is proving himself to be a ruthless gangster and “business man”.  Jack gives Johnny the heave-ho and a warning, don’t come back.

Johnny goes to find Flo, only to discover that she has become a rich nightclub owner.  Flo is also being pursued by a polite, charming, and sweet cowboy named Clarence, played by Ralph Bellamy.  Still in love with Johnny after all these years, Flo vows to help Johnny get back on top (with Clarence’s help, of course).

Johnny starts to rebuild his crew and sets about to compete with Jack Buck, who has recently entered the “protection business”.  Flo is still hoping to become Mrs. Johnny Sarto but the time is never right.  One night Johnny can’t make their date because of his dealings with Jack Buck and his gang.  He calls Flo to tell her, explaining that everything he is doing is so that he can get enough class to marry her.  Flo, feeling guilty for making Johnny work so hard and doing nothing herself, decides to help.  She decides that she will go to Jack Buck personally, and set up a meeting between him and Johnny.  To her surprise, Jack is completely willing to meet with Johnny to talk over their “misunderstanding”…but couldn’t they have the meeting far out of town?  All Flo has to do is get Johnny there, but not let him know that Jack will be there too.  Flo agrees, but has Clarence go along with her for protection.

The night of the big meeting arrives and Flo gets Johnny to the rendezvous with him none the wiser to her real intent.  Clarence sits outside in a parked car, waiting for any trouble.  Jack arrives and signals Flo away from the table, and outside someone knocks out Clarence.  Once Flo leaves the table, Jack approaches and presses a gun to Johnny’s back.  They take a walk outside, where Johnny sees Flo.  Believing that he has been betrayed, Johnny is put into a car with Jack’s men and taken away.  The idea is to get rid of Johnny, but he manages to escape from his would be assassins but not before being shot.  Wounded and exhausted, Johnny ends up at…a monastery of flower selling brothers who soon have a run in with Jack Buck’s protection services.

Based on a story written by Richard Connell for COLLIER’S MAGAZINE in 1938, BROTHER ORCHID is a really fun and funny film.  It was not one that I had heard of, but one that I really enjoyed!  Directed by Lloyd Bacon with a screen play by Earl Baldwin (and contributions from Jerry Wald and Richard Macauley), this film is a gangster movie making fun of gangster movies.  Edward G. Robinson seems to be having a great time, even appearing to poke fun at himself and his famous role as Rico in LITTLE CAESAR.

Speaking of Edward G. Robinson, I admit I often think of him as his roles as gangsters and villains such as LITTLE CAESAR and KEY LARGO.  But after watching this film, I have a much deeper appreciation for him as an actor and a greater desire to see him in some of his other roles.  Edward G. Robinson never seems too cartoony or over the top.  There is a genuineness in his acting, even when he is not the best man in the room, that makes him endlessly watchable and completely relatable.  I will definitely be seeking out more of his films!

This movie doesn’t end the way you might expect, but I felt that the ending made sense to the story and to the character of Johnny Sarto.  The message of the story isn’t all that different, a man trying to find “class” or worth in the world, but how we get there is clever and a little surprising.  All in all, this is a unique and enjoyable film that deserves to be more well known than it is.

4 thoughts on “Watching with Warner: BROTHER ORCHID (1940)

  1. Jono November 20, 2014 / 6:56 am

    My question is–when you download one of these movies to your computer, tablet or smart phone isn’t the overall screen quality considerably less than if you watch a movie on TCM on a flat screen TV?

    I head the TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES FAN CLUB OF LOS ANGELES on with over 700 L.A. area members and our members make a special effort of attending classic movie screenings in big screen theater venues around town WITH AN AUDIENCE, so the premise of trying to enjoy a classic movie streaming on-demand on a smaller than flat screen TV does not seem that enticing. But you obviously are a classic movie buff so perhaps you have a different attitude about it?


    • nowvoyaging November 20, 2014 / 7:26 am

      I would love to see all classic films on the big screen! But unfortunately where I live there are not many opportunities to do so. While I agree that seeing the film in the way it was meant to be shown, I.e. The big screen, is ideal being that many classic movie fans don’t have access to those events, the medium of SVOD is a great way to get to see films that would otherwise need to be purchased or not be seen at all. Also, I enjoy the freedom of being able to see a classic film any time or place I choose! This is especially useful having a baby at home who tends to interrupt my viewing. 😄 I also have the TCM app, but it is a little different than the Warner Archive one. And I will tell you that the version of BROTHER ORCHID I watched was in 1080 hdp and because I have the iPad and AppleTV, I was able to stream it to my television.
      I think the one thing all classic film fans want is to have classic films seen and appreciated. Seeing them on the big screen is the best of course, but I think SVOD has its place because it allows so many people to quickly access tons of classic film!

      Thank you for commenting! You are my first comment! 😀


  2. Silver Screenings November 21, 2014 / 12:54 pm

    Can’t believe I haven’t seen this one! How is that possible!! Sounds like too much fun, and with that great Warner Bros. cast as well.


    • nowvoyaging November 21, 2014 / 3:04 pm

      I know! I was surprised too! But once you watch it you might recognize some clips from TCMs “Word of Mouth” on Edward G Robinson. And it is a great film!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s